Dutton Surname DNA Project

Overview

The Dutton Surname DNA Project at Family Tree DNA is a group DNA project devoted to studying the DNA lineages of people named Dutton. Founded in 2003, it is among the oldest family group DNA projects. It has identified at least ten different Y-DNA lineages of Dutton families.

Lineages

E Haplogroups

E-L17 – Zachariah Dutton, Maryland > North Carolina

Zachariah Dutton was born around 1750 in Charles County, Maryland, where a Dutton family had been living since 1680. But Zachariah Dutton's Y-DNA does not match the main Dutton family, indicating that he was possibly an out-of-wedlock birth, a thesis supported by autosomal DNA matches between Zachariah Dutton's descendants and the descendants of Matthew Dutton of Charles County. After years of research, it now appears likely that Zachariah's father was a member of the Thomas family of Charles County.

13 Y-DNA testers, including three Big-Y 700.

• Zachariah Dutton (b. ca. 1750 Charles, Md., d. 1829 Granville, N.C.)
  • William Dutton (b. ca. 1777 Charles, Md., d. ca. 1855 Morgan, Ala.) md. Mary Hogan
    • James Zachariah Dutton (b. 1836 Morgan, Ala., d. 1899 Morgan, Ala.) md. (1) Margaret Elizabeth Hunter, (2) Mary Jane Flowers
      • 2 Y-DNA testers: #210811 (Y67), #970414 (Big-Y 700)
  • John Dutton (b. ca. 1778 Charles, Md., d. ca. 1850-1860 Morgan, Ala.) md. Omah Parrish
    • James Dutton (b. 1807 Granville, N.C., d. 1883 Walker, Ala.) md. Mary Irwin
      • 1 Y-DNA tester: #189549 (Y67)
    • Thomas Dutton (b. 1809 Granville, N.C., d. 1887 Morgan, Ala.) md. Elizabeth Kitchens
      • 1 Y-DNA tester: #102435 (Y67)
  • Alexander Dutton (b. ca. 1787 Charles, Md., d. 1818 Madison, Ala.) md. Rachel Feazel
    • Columbus Dutton (b. 1813 Madison, Ala., d. aft. 1880 Claiborne, La.) md. Catherine Huey
      • 1 Y-DNA tester: #102167 (Y67 + SNP)
  • Edmond Dutton (b. 1793 Charles, Md., d. 1882 Lawrence, Ala.) md. Margaret Barnett Ross
    • Alexander Dutton (b. 1825) (b. 1825 Lawrence, Ala., d. 1904 Love, Okla.) md. (1) Sarah Elizabeth Hampton, (2) Martha Jane Hampton
      • 1 Y-DNA tester: #101322 (Big-Y 700)
    • Stephen Penn Dutton (b. 1834 Lawrence, Ala., d. 1917 Eastland, Tex.) md. (1) Mary Frances Dutton, (2) Sarah Jane Dutton
      • 1 Y-DNA tester: #92965 (Y67)
  • Samuel Sneed Dutton (b. 1797 Granville, N.C., d. 1874 Anson, N.C.) md. Elizabeth Robinson Threadgill
    • William Cavasso Dutton (b. 1852 Anson, N.C., d. 1917 Anson, N.C.) md. Martha Jane Maner
      • 1 Y-DNA tester: #92223 (Y67)
  • Suspected NPE: Allen
    • 1 Y-DNA tester: #103871 (Y67)
  • Suspected NPE: Watts
    • 1 Y-DNA tester: #199777 (Y67)
• Philip Thomas (b. ca. 1747 Charles, Md., d. 1794 Charles, Md.) md. Mary Hungerford
  • 1 Y-DNA tester: #549307 (Big-Y 700)
• Formerly suspected NPE but disproven: Harris
  • 2 Y-DNA testers: #129122 (Y67), #880483 (Big-Y 700)

3 major branches in all.

I Haplogroups

I-M170 – Australian Dutton

Only one test at Y-DNA25 (#6687) has been conducted. No names or other information available on this lineage, other than it claims to have come from Staffordshire, England.

I-M223 > I-L623 – Ohio Duttons

Three Dutton men tested, one at Y-DNA11 and two at Y-DNA25. Two men named West also match. I have limited information on this lineage, but these lines appear to be documented:

• Stephen Dutton, born 22 Jun 1797 in Delaware, died 12 Nov 1855 Perry, Ohio, married Melora Gray.
  • Isaac Dutton, born about 1847, Ohio.
    • 1 tester, #101411 (Y25).
• William Dutton, born 7 Feb 1815 in Ohio, died 3 Sep 1846, Athens, Ohio, married Juliann King.
  • Enos Sprague Dutton, born 25 Dec 1845, Athens County, died 3 Sep 1846 Kingman, Kansas, married Martha Jane Bullard.
    • Charles Walton Dutton, born 27 May 1868 Decatur, Iowa, died 26 Oct 1959 Kingman, Kansas.
      • 1 tester, #6699 (Y25).
  • Unknown line
    • 1 tester, #8779 (Y12).
• William West, born 5 Jun 1802 in Pennsylvania, died 15 Jul 1884 in Chester, Penn., married Sarah.
  • Thomas H. B. West, born 1835 Chester, Pa., died 1900 Chesterfield, Va., married Hannah Scott.
    • 1 tester, #883325 (Big-Y 700).
  • Unknown line
    • 1 tester, #146346 (Y67).

3 lines in all.

I-M253 – Hanson Dutton, Loudoun, Virginia (b. 1799)

• Hanson Dutton, b. 3 Sep 1799 Loudoun, Va., d. 13 Jun 1888 Washington, Ohio, md. Elizabeth James.
  • Smith W. Dutton, b. 7 Apr 1825 Washington, Ohio, d. 19 May 1898 Washington, Ohio, md. Marilla Ogle.
    • Ralph William Dutton, born 14 Oct 1851 Washington, Ohio, d. 15 Jun 1910, Franklin, Ohio, md. Emma Fidella Smith.
      • 1 test, #332304 (Y37).
  • Unknown line
    • 1 test, #300594 (Y37).

Two men tested, both at Y-DNA37.

A third "California Dutton" is also haplogroup I-M253 but does not match the Hanson Dutton line. I know no other information on this lineage. A fourth U.K. Dutton also falls into haplogroup I-M253, showing as subclade I-Z2338.

R1a Haplogroups

R-M198

Two lineages of this haplogroup who don't match each other, don't have matches to other Duttons.

• Charles Norbert Dutton (b. 1860s-70s in U.K., migrated to India)
• Joseph Thomas Dutton (1839-1903), born in West Indies, may have been spelled Dotten or Dottin.

R-M512 – Derting-Darting-Dutton of Wythe County, Virginia

This family hails from Germany. Their name was originally spelled Derting or Darting, and over several generations, came to be spelled Dutton. Their descendants appear to be primarily in the Southern U.S.

• Johann Adam Derting, born 6 Jun 1720 Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany, died 5 May 1776 Shenandoah, Virginia
  • Philip Gerard Derting, born 1735 Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany, died 20 May 1776, Dunmore, Virginia
    • Adam Darting (Dutton), born 6 Mar 1770 Augusta, Virginia, died 10 Oct 1833 Wythe, Virginia; married Catherine Steffey
      • Adam Dutton Jr., born 28 Mar 1791 Wythe, Virginia, died 22 Jun 1871 Wythe, Virginia; married Elizabeth Huddle
        • David Dutton, born 21 Feb 1818 Wythe, Virginia, died 26 Sep 1854 Washington, Virginia; married Susannah Cormany
          • George Washington Dutton, born 1 Sep 1854 Tennessee, died 23 Jul 1942 Roane, Tennessee; married Susan Jennie Crow
            • Samuel William Dutton, born 22 Aug 1880 Tennessee, died 24 may 1952 Loudon, Tennessee; married Nancy Alma McNabb
              • 1 tester, #80466 (Y37)
      • Unknown line
        • Samuel Dutton, born about 1806 in Virginia, died about 1852 in Cherokee, Alabama; married Dicy J. Seymour
          • George W. Dutton, born about 1849 in Cherokee, Alabama; married 1921 Anniston, Calhoun, Alabama; married Ann Whatley
            • 1 tester #187081 (Y37)

Two tests on this line, up to Y-DNA37. I would like to see this line expanded to Big-Y 700.

R1b Haplogroups

R-DF98 – Cheshire > Pennsylvania, Maryland Duttons

The R-DF98 "Kings' Cluster" Dutton lineage has emerged as the most prominent documented Dutton lineage, which is claimed by both the Dutton family of Pennsylvania and the Duttons of Charles County, Maryland, as well as several English Duttons with documented descent from Cheshire. Notably, several branches of men with the surname Warburton also match this lineage, offering the tantalizing possibility that this line proceeds from Odard of Dutton, the founder of the Duttons of Dutton.

Pennsylvania Duttons

• John Dutton, born 1647 Overton, Cheshire, England, died 4 May 1693 Delaware, Pennsylvania; married Mary Darlington
  • John Dutton, born 25 Oct 1675 Overton, Cheshire, England, died about 1736 Delaware, Pennsylvania; married Elizabeth Kingsman
    • Kingsman Dutton, born about 1711 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died about 1765 Delaware, Pennsylvania; married Ann Routh
      • Kingsman Dutton, born about 1737 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died before 1763; married Ruth Watson
        • Kingsman Dutton, born 5 Feb 1759 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died 24 Feb 1837 Athens, Ohio; married Mary Craig
          • Samuel Dutton, born 8 Feb 1794 Hampshire, Virginia, died 7 Feb 1883 Athens, Ohio; married Nancy Brookhart
            • James Brookhart Dutton, born 21 Nov 1821 Athens, Ohio, died 10 May 1873 Athens, Ohio; married Hannah Humphrey
              • Edwin Augustus Dutton, born 26 Feb 1859 Athens, Ohio, died 31 Jan 1936 Columbus, Ohio; married Lethe Rebecca Curtis
                • 1 tester, #316047 (Y67 + SNP testing, confirmed at R-DF98)
  • Edward Dutton, born 18 Mar 1677 Overton, Cheshire, England, died about 1731 Delaware, Pennsylvania; married Gwen Williams
    • John Dutton, born about 1715 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died about 1748 Chester, Pennsylvania; married Elizabeth Dunlap
      • Samuel Dutton, born about 1736 Chester, Pennsylvania, died after 1803 Green, Kentucky; married Deborah Gregg
        • Aaron Dutton, born about 1785 Chester, Pennsylvania, died after 1850 Jefferson, Alabama; married Margaret Powell
          • Harden Dutton, born 24 Apr 1813 Lincoln, Tennessee, died 23 Jul 1885 Blount, Alabama; married Susannah Elliot
            • John B. Dutton, born 24 Feb 1855 Blount, Alabama, died 9 Aug 1924 Blount, Alabama; married Eliza Rebecca Hill
              • 1 tester, #998787 (Big-Y 700, confirmed at R-DF98 subclade)
  • Thomas Dutton, born 1 May 1679 Overton, Cheshire, England, died 10 Jan 1732, Delaware, Pennsylvania; married Lucy Barnard
    • Richard Dutton, born 8 Dec 1711 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died 18 Apr 1795 Chester, Pennsylvania
      • Jonathan Dutton, born 3 Jan 1749 Chester, Pennsylvania, died 9 Jul 1821 Delaware, Pennsylvania; married Martha Beeson
        • Richard Dutton, born 12 Aug 1776 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died 15 Feb 1854 Chester, Pennsylvania; married Lydia Larkin
          • Jonathan Dutton, born 16 Jul 1814 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died 1900 Pennsylvania; married Elizabeth Jane Bullock
            • Reese Roberts Dutton, born 20 Dec 1841 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died 24 Apr 1928 Washington, D.C.; married Rachel Louise Jefferis
              • 1 tester, #102173 (Y25)
        • Jonathan Dutton, born 9 Jan 1784 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died 27 Jul 1861 Delaware, Pennsylvania; married Rachel Pennell
          • William Henry Dutton, born 12 Jul 1831 Delaware, Pennsylvania, died 15 May 1908 Delaware, Pennsylvania; married Mary Emma Butler
            • William Henry Dutton Jr., born 9 Dec 1873 Pennsylvania, died 8 Dec 1932 Delaware, Pennsylvania; married Priscilla Habbersett
              • 1 tester, #12715 (Y37 + SNP testing, confirmed at R-U106)

Maryland Duttons

• Thomas Dutton, born about 1660 England, died about 1695 Charles, Maryland; married Elizabeth Hill
  • Matthew Dutton, born 28 Sep 1692 Charles, Maryland, died 1734 Charles, Maryland; married Judith O'Caine
    • Notley Dutton Sr., born about 1720 Charles, Maryland, died about 1801 Charles, Maryland; married ? Chunn
      • Notley Dutton Jr., born about 1740 Charles, Maryland, died about 1801 Charles, Maryland; married Eleanor Philpot Glover
        • Notley Dutton, born 31 Jan 1787 Charles, Maryland, died after 1830 Charles, Maryland; married ? Yates
          • Notley Thomas Dutton, born about 1815 Charles, Maryland, died 28 Sep 1865 Charles, Maryland; married Angeline E. {maiden name unknown}
            • Edwin Carpenter Dutton, born 10 Sep 1849 St. Mary's Maryland, died 26 Feb 1890 Charles, Maryland; married Lucy Colton Dutton
              • 1 tester, #159028 (Big Y-700 confirmed at R-DF98 subclade)
    • Gerrard Dutton, born about 1732 Charles, Maryland, died about 1790 Charles, Maryland; married Ann {maiden name unknown}
      • James Henry Dutton, born about 1774 Charles, Maryland, died after 1840 Charles, Maryland; married Elizabeth Dutton
        • George Washington Dutton, born 7 Jan 1829 Charles, Maryland, died 2 Nov 1913 Washington, D.C.; married Susan Malvina Harrison
          • Robert William Dutton, born 21 Jun 1857 Washington, D.C., died 22 May 1934 Washington, D.C.; married Marguerite Harrington Langley
            • 2 testers, #159028 (Big Y-700, confirmed at R-DF98 subclade) and #318507 (Y111 + SNP testing, confirmed at R-DF98 subclade)

England Duttons

• Richard Dutton, born Oct 1781 Burwardsley, Cheshire, England, died 20 Dec 1857 Tattenhall, Cheshire, England; married Rachel Wright
  • Edward Dutton, born about 1821 Tattenhall, Cheshire, England, died 12 Jan 1906 Hatton Heath, Cheshire, England; married Martha Robinson Harnot
    • John Robinson Dutton, born 24 May 1855 Winmarleigh, Lancashire, England, died 8 Sep 1933 Gilbert Plains, Manitoba, England; married Anna Nicol
      • 1 tester, #331088 (Y67 + SNP testing; confirmed at R-DF98)
• William Dutton, born 1851 London, died before 1939 London; married Kate Eliza Storey
  • 1 tester, #N49453 (Y111 + SNP testing, confirmed at R-DF98)

Twelve testers, including five at Big Y-700, two at Y111, three at Y67, one at Y37, and one at Y25.

R-M222 – David Dutton, Pennsylvania > Ohio

David Dutton, born about 1756 in Pennsylvania, was believed by Gilbert Cope to be a son of Kingsman Dutton (b. 1711) and Anne Routh, of the John Dutton of Pennsylvania family (see #R-DF98 – Cheshire > Pennsylvania, Maryland Duttons), but Y-DNA does not bear this out, at least not a biological connection. Cope may have received mistaken information, or it is possible David Dutton was an adopted child or foster child. See also #Francis Dutton, Pennsylvania > Ohio.

• David Dutton, born about 1756 Pennsylvania, died 5 Dec 1836 Harrison, Ohio; married Hannah Rodgers
  • Robert Dutton, born 2 Sep 1788 Berkeley, Virginia, died 20 Apr 1845 Jefferson, Ohio; married Abigail Matson
    • Nehemiah Dutton, born 27 Dec 1830 Belmont, Ohio, died 14 Aug 1911 Jefferson, Ohio; married Phoebe Catherine Huntsman
      • William Robert Dutton, born 20 Sep 1858 Ohio, died 30 May 1934 Newton, Missouri; married Ellen Eliza Ogilbee
        • 2 testers, #6688 (Y25 + SNP testing, confirmed at R-M222 subclade), #111319 (Y37 + SNP testing, confirmed at R-M222)

Two testers, one Y25 and one Y37, both with additional SNP testing.

R-M269

Massachusetts Duttons: Thomas Dutton, b. 1621 in England, d. 1687 Middlesex, Mass.

Thomas Dutton is supposed to have been born in Chester or Gloucester, England, supposedly from the line of the Duttons of Dutton, but his descendants do not match other known Cheshire Duttons, either the Pennsylvania-Maryland Duttons or the South Carolina Duttons. This lineage appears to be a relatively rare haplotype (only about a dozen matches at 11 STR markers), but more testing is needed to refine its haplogroup and origins.

• Thomas Dutton, born 6 Oct 1621 Cheshire or Gloucestershire, England, died 22 Jan 1686 Middlesex, Massachusetts; married Susannah Palmer
  • Thomas Dutton, born 14 Sep 1648 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 1 Jan 1728 Middlesex, Massachusetts; married Rebecca Brabrook
    • Thomas Dutton, born 2 Aug 1681 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 4 Aug 1759 Middlesex, Massachusetts; married Hannah Burge
      • Ephraim Dutton Sr., born 1 Jan 1728 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 1807 Springfield, Vermont; married Thankful Seaver
        • Ephraim Dutton Jr., born 30 Aug 1753 Worcester, Massachusetts, died 19 Aug 1840 Windsor, Vermont; married Susannah Bixby
          • Asa Dutton, born 30 Dec 1781 Windsor, Vermont, died 25 Nov 1860 Brown, Ohio; married Eunice Townsend
            • Solomon Dutton, born 12 Oct 1808 Kennebec, Maine, died 29 Mar 1827 Brown, Ohio; married Mary Frances Brooks
              • John Brooks Dutton, born 24 Jan 1832 Brown, Ohio, died 4 Mar 1879 Brown, Ohio; married Nancy Ann Hendrickson
                • Jesse Lee Dutton, born 31 Dec 1875 Brown, Ohio, died 17 Aug 1937 Allen, Indiana; married Mary Celestia Evans
                  • 1 tester, #31202 (Y67)
  • John Dutton, born 28 Mar 1656 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 7 Apr 1735 Middlesex, Massachusetts; married Sarah Shed
    • Samuel Dutton, born 22 Mar 1692 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 8 Jan 1836 Middlesex, Massachusetts; married Hannah Walker Hill
      • Samuel Dutton, born 15 Oct 1718 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 1802 Windham, Vermont; married Martha Lane
        • Asa Dutton, born 18 Mar 1759 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 11 Feb 1836 Windham, Vermont; married Mary Tarble
          • Asa Dutton, born 13 May 1791 Windham, Vermont, died 23 Mar 1868 Georgetown, New York; married Mary Day
            • Lorenzo Dow Dutton, born 25 Nov 1816 Otsego, New York, died 15 Mar 1889 Chippewa, Wisconsin; married Eunice Diana Maxon
              • William Henry Dutton, born 30 Jul 1842 Madison, New York, died 1 Oct 1908 Saskatchewan, Canada; married Esther Alnora Randall
                • William Henry Dutton, born 18 Nov 1867 Madison, New York, died 18 Apr 1939 Eau Claire, Wisconsin; married Elizabeth Dolan
                  • 1 tester, #234109 (Y37)
    • Jonathan Dutton, born 4 Feb 1699 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 23 Apr 1768 Middlesex, Massachusetts; married Sarah Levistone
      • John Dutton, born 14 Apr 1723 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 1760 Middlesex, Massachusetts; married Mehitable Patten
        • Jesse Dutton, born 9 Jul 1747 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 15 Jan 1816 Kennebec, Maine; married Mary Tredwell
          • John Dutton, born 1 Jun 1773 Kennebec, Maine, died 15 Dec 1875 Suffolk, Massachusetts; married Ann Gardner
            • James Twing Dutton, born 27 Apr 1831 Suffolk, Massachusetts, died 12 Mar 1904 Boston, Massachusetts; married Adelia Ludlum
              • John Austin Dutton, born 4 Mar 1868 Brooklyn, New York, died 29 Mar 1929 Braintree, Massachusetts; married Helen May Skinner
                • 1 tester, #16547 (Y67)
  • Joseph Dutton, born 25 Jan 1661 Middlesex, Massachusetts, died 24 Jan 1733 Middlesex, Connecticut; married Mary Smith
    • David Dutton, born 1701 Middlesex, Connecticut, died 1774 Litchfield, Connecticut; married Sarah Abernathy
      • Amos Dutton, born 1745 New Haven, Connecticut, died 1788 New Haven Connecticut; married Sarah Turner
        • Enos Dutton, born 1770 New Haven, Connecticut, died 1850 Schoharie, New York; married Chloe Warner
          • Julius Dutton, born 1792 Litchfield, Connecticut, died 1870 Schoharie, New York; married Matilda Lay
            • Horace Dutton, born 8 Aug 1817 Schoharie, New York, died 3 Feb 1898 Rice, Minnesota; married Catherine E. Wilson
              • Melvin O. Dutton, born 20 Dec 1842 Schoharie, New York, died between 1910 and 1920; married Henrietta M. Becker
                • Melvin Ometa Dutton, born 7 Oct 1869 Clarke, Iowa, died 9 Nov 1953 Meade, South Dakota; married Martha Ellice Twombley
                  • 1 tester, #87477 (Y11)
    • Thomas Dutton, born 1 Mar 1707 Middlesex, Connecticut, died 16 Apr 1799 Windsor, Vermont; married Abigail Merriam
      • Asahel Dutton, born 16 Feb 1750 New Haven, Connecticut, died 1776 Litchfield, Connecticut; married Sarah Frisbie Northrop
        • Asahel Dutton, born 8 Mar 1774 Litchfield, Connecticut, died 1821 Gallatin, Illinois; married Irene Brazier
          • Asahel William Dutton, born about 1851 Illinois, died 1880 Hardin, Illinois
            • William (Edward) Dutton, born 20 Dec 1874 Hardin, Illinois, died 1955 Hardin, Illinois; married Dora Ann Page
              • 2 testers, #6828 (Y67), #87477 (Y11)
• 1 matching tester from unknown but matching line, #N50638 (Y11)

Seven matching tests on this line, three at Y-DNA11, one at Y-DNA37, and three at Y-DNA67. I would very much like to see this line upgraded.

Francis Dutton, Pennsylvania > Ohio

Gilbert Cope supposed Francis Dutton was a son of Kingsman Dutton (b. 1711) and Anne Routh, but Y-DNA does not bear this out, at least not with a biological connection. It is possible that Cope received mistaken information, or it is possible that Francis was an adopted or foster son.

• Francis Dutton, born about 1745 Chester, Pennsylvania, died 1836 Belmont, Ohio; married (1) Hannah Talbot, (2) Lydia Booth
  • Isaac Dutton, born 24 Sep 1798 Washington, Pennsylvania, died 13 Apr 1843 Delaware, Ohio; married Anna Smith
    • Isaac Booth Dutton, born 4 Sep 1827 Marion, Ohio, died 9 Jan 1910 Los Angeles, California; married Rebecca Jane Smith
      • Harry Arnold Dutton, born about 1873 Kansas, died 2 Jan 1957 Jalisco, Mexico
        • 1 tester, #6793 (Y25)
  • Jacob Dutton, born 4 Jan 1807 Belmont, Ohio, d. 8 Sep 1872 Carroll, Ohio; married Rachael Plowman
    • Jacob Plowman Dutton, born 23 Jul 1844 Massillon, Ohio, died 3 Oct 1914 Ohio; married Mary Ellen Benedum
      • John Plowman Dutton, born 14 Dec 1877 Carroll, Ohio, died 16 May 1955 Harrison, Ohio; married Theresa Henry
        • 1 tester, #161718 (Y11)
  • Unknown lines
    • 2 testers, #161845 (Y11) and #19063 (Y25)

Four testers, two at Y11 and two at Y25.

Dutton-Dunton, various lines

Five tests whose matching status is uncertain: One line tested at Y-DNA11 matches the others but may not match further out. One at Y-DNA25 with claimed Cheshire descent matches another at Y-DNA111 (confirmed to be haplogroup R1b-P312) with no other information given. Two others at Y-DNA37 don't appear to match. I would appreciate more information on these lines.

R-DF13 – Cheshire > South Carolina Duttons

This line descends from a Dutton family which can first be documented in the Old Ninety-Six District of South Carolina around the 1770s. In the past, this line has been associated with Jeremiah Dutton, shown on early Ninety-Six District tax lists and censuses, but I have found no conclusive evidence tying this line to Jeremiah Dutton.

This line shows strong of having origins in Cheshire, England. These testers show more distant Y-DNA matches (primarily at Y37) to men with documented Cheshire origins, including men named Marsh and Warburton. Several other match names have origins in Lancashire and Yorkshire.

• Thomas Dutton, born about 1770 South Carolina, died after 1840 Elbert, Georgia
  • Thomas C. Dutton, born about 1796 Elbert, Georgia, died after 1860 Blount, Alabama; married Miriam {maiden name unknown}
    • Henry G. Dutton, born about 1829 Georgia, died 19 Jan 1911 Morgan, Alabama; married (1) Elizabeth Frazier, (2) Mary C. Wilson
      • David N. Dutton, born 4 Mar 1871 Chattooga, Georgia, died 8 Jul 1928 Morgan, Alabama; married (1) Cassie N. Franklin, (2) Lee Emma Lawrence
        • 1 tester, #1004371 (Big-Y 700)
• John Dutton, born about 1774 South Carolina, died after 1850 Washington, Arkansas; married Susannah Stepp
  • James Cass Dutton, born about 1808 Virginia, died about 1865 Washington Arkansas; married Matilda Mollett
    • Andrew Jackson Dutton, born 12 Dec 1842 Kentucky, died 19 Mar 1921 Coryell, Texas; married (1) Louanna Sizemore, (2) Catherine Beech
      • George Washington Dutton, born 6 Oct 1865 Washington, Arkansas, died 4 Apr 1951 Benton, Arkansas; married Ella Josephine Parsley
        • 1 tester, #30064 (Y37)
      • William Daniel Dutton, born 17 Jul 1869 Coryell, Texas, died 9 Feb 1948 Coryell, Texas; married Nancy Elizabeth Sleeker
        • 1 tester, #281145 (Big-Y 700)

Three testers, including two Big-Y 700.

A fourth man who distantly matches this group at Y37 descends from Samuel Austin Alibone Dutton (born 1858 Phildadelphia, died New York City 1930).